Makale detayı · 2010
Ontological (In)security and State Denial of Historical Crimes: Turkey and Japan
- Yıl
- 2010
- Tür
- article
Veri kaynağı ayrımı
- YÖKSİS YÖKSİS makale kaydı
- YÖKSİS dergi adı INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
- Katalog eşleşmesi (ISSN) International Relations
- OpenAlex OpenAlex zenginleştirmesi (özet, atıf, konular)
Özet
OpenAlex · İngilizce
This article joins the growing scholarship on the ontological security needs of states. By focusing on state denial of historical crimes, the article will address the main point of contention among scholars who study ontological security, i.e. the question of whether identity pressures on states are mostly endogenously or exogenously generated. Through a study of the Turkish state’s reluctance to apologize for the Armenian genocide, and the Japanese discomfort over the WWII atrocities, I argue that we can avoid tautology in our generalizations by introducing temporal and spatial dimensions to the argument. Inter-subjective pressures matter more at times when traditional routines defining the self are broken and are more likely to create ontological insecurity outside the West. The review of the Turkish and Japanese cases demonstrate that both social and individualistic approaches to ontological security are partly right, but also incomplete because neither takes into account the uneven expansion of international society or the effect this expansion has had on the identity of outsider states who were incorporated into the system at a later date.
Konular
Atıflar
OpenAlex cited_by_count. WoS veya Scopus atıf sayısı değildir; o kaynaklar için ayrı kolon yoktur.
421 atıf
OpenAlex cited_by_count (önbellek / veritabanı)
Yerel katalogda bu makaleye atıf yapan 32 yayın (OpenAlex referans eşleşmesi; tam dünya listesi değildir).
- Hierarchies in World Politics 2016
- Struggles for Recognition: The Liberal International Order and the Merger of Its Discontents 2021
- Struggles for recognition: The liberal international order and the merger of its discontents 2022
- What made the modern world hang together: socialisation or stigmatisation? 2014
- States and ontological security: A historical rethinking 2017
- Ontological insecurity in asymmetric conflicts: Reflections on agonistic peace in Turkey’s Kurdish issue 2017
- Cultural intimacy in International Relations 2013
- Breaking with Europe’xxs pasts: memory, reconciliation, and ontological (In)security 2018
- Turkey's ambivalent self: ontological insecurity in 'Kemalism' versus 'Erdoganism' 2019
- What makes terrorism modern? Terrorism, legitimacy, and the international system 2011